Does Ahrefs DR4 Punish Sites With Many Badges? Our Four-Site Investigation
Stay Up, Name to Avatar, Brightwood Stories, and ShowBuild had very different DR4 outcomes. We compared their badges and backlinks to see what the pattern can tell us.

When Ahrefs previewed Domain Rating 4 (DR4), Stay Up fell from DR3 39 to DR4 5. Name to Avatar fell from 34 to 6. Both had spent time collecting startup directory listings and displaying badges on their sites.
Then we checked Brightwood Stories. It had little directory submission activity and no comparable collection of badges, yet its DR4 was 6. We found a fourth site, ShowBuild, that runs a directory and offers reciprocal badge links much like Stay Up. Its DR rose from 42 to 44, and we did not see a directory badge collection on its homepage.
That contrast raised a question: does DR4 discount sites that display many directory badges? We compared the sites' scores, referring domains, and visible badge practices. The pattern is interesting, but the evidence does not establish a badge penalty.
The four websites that raised the question
| Website | DR3 | DR4 | Change | Directory badges on homepage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stay Up | 39 | 5 | -34 | Yes, before our changes |
| Name to Avatar | 34 | 6 | -28 | Yes |
| Brightwood Stories | 8 | 6 | -2 | None observed |
| ShowBuild | 42 | 44 | +2 | None observed |
Ahrefs DR3 and DR4 preview scores observed in November 2026. Homepage badges reflect what we saw during this investigation; these sites and scores can change.
Brightwood Stories is a small project whose known backlinks come largely from our other projects. We had not been actively submitting it to startup directories. Its modest decline stood out next to the much larger drops for Stay Up and Name to Avatar.
The starting scores matter, though. A two-point change from DR3 8 is not directly comparable to a 34-point change from DR3 39. Domain Rating is a relative, logarithmic measure, so the difference alone cannot tell us which kind of link DR4 valued less.
ShowBuild made the comparison more intriguing. Like Stay Up, it is a directory with paid listings and a reciprocal badge program, and Ahrefs labels both sites as spam. Yet ShowBuild's DR increased while Stay Up's fell. The spam label alone does not explain these two outcomes.
What Ahrefs says changed in DR4
Ahrefs says DR4 draws authority from a smaller pool of linking sites, gives more weight to links from sites with estimated organic search traffic, and rates subdomains independently. It also reports larger median declines among spam-labeled domains in a particular DR3 range.
Ahrefs' description of Domain Rating focuses on incoming backlinks, the strength of the linking sites, and how widely those sites link out. Its published explanation does not identify an explicit penalty for displaying outbound directory badges.
That leaves at least two possible explanations for what we saw. DR4 might value some directory or reciprocal backlinks much less than DR3 did. Or outgoing badge patterns might affect the score in a way Ahrefs has not described. Our comparison cannot distinguish between them.
For more context on the update, see our earlier DR4 and DR3 backlink comparison.
More backlinks did not mean a higher DR4
We compared followed referring domains for Stay Up and ShowBuild in a separate backlink index. The results favored Stay Up on raw counts:
| Metric | Stay Up | ShowBuild |
|---|---|---|
| Followed referring domains | 109 | 55 |
| Total backlinks | 68,784 | 3,910 |
| Ahrefs DR4 | 5 | 44 |
Backlink counts from DataForSEO, checked November 12, 2026. DataForSEO and Ahrefs use different indexes and methods; these counts do not determine Ahrefs DR4.
The total backlink count is especially misleading here. Two domains account for about 96.8% of the backlinks reported for Stay Up, largely through links repeated across their pages. Thousands of links from one domain are not thousands of independent endorsements.
Even the unique referring-domain count does not settle the question. Ahrefs may have found links that the other index missed, or may assign very different weight to the links both tools found. Its free Backlink Checker showed 121 linking websites for ShowBuild, while the other index found 55 followed referring domains. Those figures use different definitions and cannot be compared as though they were the same measure.
We also checked a sample of ShowBuild's referring sites. Most had low DR4 scores, and the organic traffic estimates available for several of them were low. One potentially strong referring domain appeared in Ahrefs' sample, but we could not verify a live link from its public page. This sample did not reveal a clear explanation for ShowBuild's DR4 44; it also cannot rule out stronger links elsewhere.
Receiving a badge link is different from displaying badges
ShowBuild receives links from sites that display its badge. Stay Up had a collection of badges linking out to other directories. These are different sides of a reciprocal link arrangement.
Brightwood Stories and ShowBuild had no comparable homepage badge collection when we looked. Stay Up and Name to Avatar did, and both saw large DR4 declines. Four websites are too few to isolate the cause. They differ in age, backlink mix, content, search visibility, and many other ways.
An explanation that fits Ahrefs' published account is that some incoming directory links now pass less value. That could lower a site's DR without any penalty for the badges it displays. An additional effect from outgoing badges is possible, but we have no direct evidence that Ahrefs subtracts DR because a site displays them.
We reduced Stay Up's badges and will watch what happens
Some directory badges were a condition for obtaining or keeping a backlink. Reducing them can cost us those links, so this is a tradeoff rather than a risk-free cleanup.
We reduced the number of directory image badges detected on Stay Up's homepage from 31 to 25. In the same November 12 snapshots, followed external links went from 35 to 19, while nofollow external links went from 0 to 10. Some retained badges were hidden separately; the link snapshots do not capture every visibility change.
We will watch whether Ahrefs recrawls the page, whether incoming links change, and whether DR4 moves. Even if the score rises, that alone will not prove a badge penalty. Ahrefs could update its index or the ratings of referring domains at the same time.
What should directory users take from this?
We do not yet know whether DR4 penalizes badge-heavy sites. The comparison gives us a reason to investigate, not a reason to claim causation.
For now, evaluate each directory placement on its own terms. Check whether the listing reaches relevant people, whether its link is live, and what the badge requirement costs you in space and maintenance. Our guide to choosing a startup directory covers those practical checks. A directory's old DR3 score alone is a weak reason to pursue its backlink.
We will revisit the question after Ahrefs has had time to recrawl Stay Up and we can compare the next observations. If you have seen a large DR4 change alongside a badge-heavy homepage, your experience could help show whether this pattern extends beyond these four sites.
Research period: November 5–13, 2026. This is an observational comparison of four websites, not a controlled experiment. DR4 values were preview scores at the time of checking, and third-party backlink inventories are incomplete.